James Sure, but tell me this. You may prefer to be belted. Would you still say the same for belt AND thigh bands, or belt AND thigh bands AND metal bra?
Sorry, but I have to say this. I think these questions make no sense other then giving you sexual arousement.
As far as I understand no one here can choose between anything. If a chastity belt is part of your family routine, you will be belted, if spanking and punishment is part of your family routine, you will be spanked.
For me it's in addition. I have to wear my belt 24/7, I have to wear my tight bands from dinner to the next morning and I will receive my weekly maintenance spanking in less than 4 hours. It's not that I ever had a choice or will have until I meet Mr. Right.
If anything goes as I expected, I can make ONE descision about this in my life. The descision how I want to live my married life. As a good submissive woman or as a free woman in a marriage based on equality. If the first option is true, it's again not about me to define when, how or why I get punished or belted, if it is the second option, I will never have to present my body for punishment or a chastity belt ever again.
Thinking if I would prefer chastity devices or punishments will lead to nothing. It is not my choice and will never be.