Tjc
Lots of things mean being emotionally dependent. Lack of emotional dependence or connection is a sign of poor mental health.
Dependance and connection are far from being synonims
Lack of dependence means being an INdependent adult.
Phisically limit doing experiences (traveling, going to beach, relocating away, etc)
This does not necessarily apply to a correctly fitted belt and a well design program.
Now you will explain me how to go to a gym or beach with a chastity belt fitted with tight bands.
Then, doing unhealthy things is not so wrong, it happens to everyone.
But it will not convince me it's a good idea, and your situation is not something I will suggest to a friend with exactly the same issues.
You made a good poll but many, if not all, of these things are not yes or no, black or white issues.
But you can express opinions. This poll is about our opinions. For me it's pretty black, as every parental abuse. Beating is another pretty black, as it is any kind of sexual interactions. There are shades of grey? Sometimes, but not always. Sometimes, for some things, they are just wrong. FGM, minor prostitution are examples, but also limiting access to body, conditional love, etc
I am curious what you would suggest to a friend in the same situation @Sasha found herself in, given to ongoing success of her solution.
Situation can be the same, but people are different. Girls outside control happen. Chastity belt doesn’t . Removing from bad environment / committed to specific studies / therapy / transfer into protected environment are all valid solutions.
Sasha is happy this way? Ok, I have no intention to undermine his happiness or satisfaction. Do I believe that it can work for someone else? No, but again it’s my opinion